Hypothesis and bets

I recently wrote this note to subscribers as part of a company analysis. I have removed names for obvious reason, but the point I am making remains valid.

—————

This is a good example of how most ideas work (if they are successful). It takes time and patience to stick around for a thesis to play out. The stock market is an efficient place and one should not assume that other investors are idiots. In most cases the market is right and is discounting the near-term results into the price. As a result, it may undervalue a company which has good long-term growth prospects but is facing temporary challenges.

The job of an investor is to evaluate if the challenges are temporary or permanent. If you think it is temporary, then it makes sense to start investing into the company via a small position. The reason for starting with a small position is to be open to the possibility that one is wrong about the hypothesis.

I have a reason why I always use the word hypothesis. It has a precise meaning. It does not mean a forecast or a guess. It means possibility or ‘what can happen’. The future is always indeterminate and as an investor one needs to consider the range of possibilities.

Think bets

This means that one starts with a small bet and raises the bet as more data comes in. This is the equivalent of starting with a small bet in poker and raising your hand as new cards open up (information comes in). If the data or cards do not fall your way – you fold your hand or sell out of the position.

If you have watched poker, you would have noticed that even the best players fold a lot of hands when they realize that the cards have not come their way, or they have made a mistake. Investing is similar. If you have made a mistake or data comes in such that the negative scenario appears more likely, then you reduce the size of the bet or fold your hand.

On the contrary, If the data starts pointing to the optimistic scenario (growth is returning back, ROCE is improving etc), then we start raising the size of the bet or in other words our position size.

This is what I am doing all the time – taking an initial position with a few hypotheses in mind and then raising or dropping the position size based on how the company performs or how the data comes in.

In some cases, the favorable scenario (which in my view has a higher probability) works out. In the case of company X, as growth returned we have raised the position. In some other cases, the growth and improvement in economics is yet to happen – we have kept the position size the same. In a few cases, if things worsen or if I am wrong, we drop or eliminate the position.

Right expectations

Why I have taken this detour in the quarterly update? I have sometimes received emails expressing surprise that I have turned pessimistic after sounding positive for a long time. In all these cases I am watching the company and industry and as the data changes or some events occur, I have changed my view of the company (sometimes late).

How else should one react? Should I just stick to my view so that I appear all confident and smart while I drive our portfolio and capital over the cliff? For our collective sakes, I hope that I can avoid my ego from getting in the way of making rational decisions. In the past, I would fret about it. Now, I just ignore and take the necessary decision irrespective of how I appear to others.

As a side note, there is another pattern you should observe. As the market discounts the next 1-2 years performance correctly, it means that the minimum time it will take for an idea to show results has to be more than that. In 2017, the market was discounting 2018 and early 2019 performance for Company X. As growth improved for FY19 and FY20, the market has taken note of it and started discounting the same.