Latest stories

Preparing for a downturn

P

We published this note to all our subscribers today


I have been doing a detailed analysis of the past bear markets of 2008, 2016, 2018, 2020 and 2022. I looked at the indices, individual stocks and our past holdings during this period. It has allowed to me understand context of the market and mistakes I made during these periods.

I am listing a few learnings from this study. This should give you a context of our actions in the recent months during which our cash levels rose from 6% to 33% now

The current market reminds me most of the 2007/early 2008 and 2017/early 2018 period. It does not mean that we will have a financial crisis later this year. Please keep in mind that it is about similarities with these periods, but you cannot use it to forecast the market

A few learnings

No one can predict the market but often there are signs of froth, and it makes sense to become cautious. One can guess ‘what’ may happen, even if you cannot figure out when it will happen

  • Valuation extremes: In the past, when valuations hit the extremes, it took months for the excesses to be wrung out of the system. Valuations are now at their 10+ year high in the small cap/mid cap space. Promoters have been launching IPO/QIP etc to raise capital when it is cheap
  • Deep corrections: Theme stocks of the current cycle, no matter how good the prospects, get hit the most and can easily drop 50% or more. Other stocks will not be spared as indices drop 10-30% from peak to trough
  • Nowhere to hide: During deep corrections, there is no place to hide, and all stocks will be impacted. The key is to remain invested in those companies with a robust business model and good growth prospects for the next 2-3 years

Mistakes from the past

We made the following mistakes which I am trying to avoid now

  • We were concentrated in a few sectors/ stocks in the previous downcycle. When these stocks were hit, our portfolio had a big impact
  • We kept buying or held on to stocks which were in continuous down trend. A lot of these companies did not recover for another 2-3 years
  • Heavy losses made us risk averse and we were not prepared enough when the market turned

Some recent actions

  1. Reduce valuation risk – We have reduced or eliminated positions where the valuation was much higher than the median. This was to reduce the valuation risk in the portfolio
  2. Reduce concentration risk – We have reduced the size of some positions which are fairly valued. This was done to reduce the concentration risk
  3. Exit weak sectors – We have exited some stocks where the stock and the sector seem to be topping off and growth is slowing such as the FMCG space

Go forward plan

We have not started a new position for some time.  As we have shared in the past, we will not invest to show activity from our side and justify our fees. We will act only when the risk reward is favorable

Just because the market is down 10% does not mean that it’s a good time to buy. If you expect steady stream of ideas, you will be disappointed as markets don’t work that way. There are times to be active and then times to just wait and prepare

We continue to monitor all our positions and will not hesitate to exit or reduce some of them if the risk reward is not great. Just because a stock is already down, or a turnaround is around the corner is not the right way to make decision.

Experience in prior bear market has taught us that hope is a bad strategy. Take your hits, clean the slate and conserve your financial and mental capital. We will be ready whenever the market turns

Learning and feeling dumb

L

I started my career in Marketing and switched to IT (consulting). The pay was 2X and the stress was half of that. I had also come to the realization that I did not enjoy sales/marketing. Reading and learning was the thing I loved, and IT provided a great opportunity for that. Investing was the other area where I could the same and earn at the same time

I joined one of the Large IT services companies and was deployed on an ERP project. I had no clue about the technology. I tackled the problem the same way I had handled it as an investor

I went online, downloaded the implementation guides, manuals, notes – whatever I could find and started reading them. At first, they made no sense. However, by the third reading (cover to cover), I started getting a hang of it

The next step was to get into the software and practice. I became good at it within a year.

On the next project, I had some juniors working with me who were in the same place, I was a year back. To my surprise, when I asked them to read all the material, cover to cover, they balked at it. Till the end of the project, they kept reaching out to me for help and just coasted along

Most people avoid lifelong learning

At the end of this episode and a few years later, I realized a couple of things

  • These colleagues did reasonably well in other companies and moved into managerial roles. It just showed that learning was not key in moving up the ladder and most companies did not care for it.
  • There is a perverse system where a lot of IT service companies do not reward for deep expertise. As a result, they end up with a layer of management who have outdated technology skills. It is not their loss though as they tend to fire such resources when they get bloated
  • Curiosity and drive to learn is not as common as I thought. Most of the people I know would rather coast along without pushing themselves

Why people avoid learning

Initially I was puzzled why people avoided learning when it was fun, and you were better off in the end

I realized that the process of learning makes you feel stupid. I recently went through this phase when I was learning technical analysis and poker a few years back. Even now, I get the same feeling on a regular basis. This is not a question of intelligence. No one likes to feel dumb and as a result people avoid learning new things

This will be a major hurdle in the future for a lot of people as new AI based technologies go mainstream. I have gone down that rabbit hole in the last 2 years and can see massive changes on the horizon.

Unfortunately, a lot of people will complain and find reasons to avoid the discomfort of learning. I am lucky that I am comfortable with feeling lost and stupid most of the time. I have 25 years of practice in it

Here we go again

H

A recent post to our subscribers on the current market situation. Hope you find it useful


We have experienced 13 drops of more than 10% in the last 14 years of our advisory. A few have been more than 20% and the one in 2020 was 30%+

If you have been in the equity market for a long time, this is not a surprise. Even a cursory study of market history, shows the same. Yet, a lot of people get shocked by such drops.

The recent drop is being explained with a new set of reasons whereas just a few months back, India was being touted as a miracle economy. If you really need a reason, how about this? – The markets fell as it often has in the past and will do so from time to time in the future

A study of the past

I recently did a talk about past cycles of manias and booms & busts. You can watch the recording here. Some of the key lessons are

  • Manias and crashes are driven by human nature. They will always be there as long as people are trading in the markets
  • There is a plausible, kernel of truth which gets stretched to excess
  • No one can predict when/where a bubble will start and when it will end
  • Media always acts as a cheer leader of Bubbles (Story/Attention Bias)

As part of this study, we also reviewed the past 25 years of the Indian market. We have incorporated the learnings in a new process, where we review the market on a monthly basis to gauge its trend, breadth and sectors which are doing well and ones that are slowing down

As a result of this review and rising valuations, we started exiting some positions and are now at 25% cash levels

Did I foresee that the market would drop? No amount of market analysis can help you forecast the future. What we did realize was that some companies in our portfolio were stretched and so we started pulling back. We also exited positions where the performance was poor and the stock was weakening

In a nutshell, we raised our cash level as the risk reward ratio in our portfolio dropped

So what about the cash?

The next set of questions, we invariably get after every drop, is when we plan to invest the cash. For starters, we are not swing traders who are trying to catch the swing low to make a 20% gain on the next bounce

Our focus is to buy stocks with a 2-3 yr window and a 10% drop is not enough. Several stocks have dropped from a PE of 100 to 70. That is not cheap

We are constantly searching for new ideas and that process continues independent of the market condition. A bear market turns up more ideas for consideration, but we are not in a hurry. We have slept well and made reasonable returns inspite of holding high cash from time to time. We will continue in the same manner

The psychology of stoploss

T

I wrote this to our subscribers recently. Hope you find it useful

Why be cautious

It is easy to swing for the fences. If we had been fully invested and had higher allocation to some positions, our returns would be higher. However, I have been a proponent of the principle The number one goal of investing is survival.

This does not mean we won’t lose money at the position or portfolio level from time to time. Our goal is to have losses from which we can recover financially and psychologically. Most investors underestimate damage to the psyche after a huge drawdown. All high return strategies appear great in hindsight, but usually have 50%+ draw downs in them. It is easy to see such drawdowns on paper and completely different to experience it.

I am certain that less than 1% of investors can tolerate a 50%+ drawdown and continue to invest in the same manner as before. Most throw in the towel, never to return to the markets. There is no point in following an approach you cannot stick with, especially when the going gets tough

The psychology of stoploss

This is another change we introduced in the last few years to manage risk. I never used a stop loss for 20 years and found the idea contrary to buy and hold. If you plan to hold a position for the long term and it drops in price, then it surely is cheaper, and one should add more?

We have done that in the past, before we got hit by a few failures in 2018 and 2020

As I mulled over this issue, I realized that buy & hold works only as a special case – my analysis is correct and there is no change in the underlying thesis. In these failures, I got the analysis wrong, or the thesis changed. Holding onto such positions is financial suicide

We review a host of fundamental and technical factors to arrive at a stop loss number, which also depends on the type of setup. A long term buy and hold position has a much wider stop loss compared to a momentum stock

More than the number though, a stop loss acts as a line in the sand. It allows us to exit the position and look at it at a later point without any baggage.

The most important benefit for us is psychological. It has allowed me to be more aggressive with new ideas as I know that our downside is capped. In absence of a stop loss, the downside risk would have me worried, and we would often miss the idea. In other words, the idea of stop loss has been mentally liberating


Disclaimer

  • This report is published by RC Capital Management – SEBI Registered Investment Advisor (INA000004088).
  • This report is for educational purposes only and should not be construed as an Investment Advice.
  • RC Capital Management may have recommended the above stocks to our clients in the past. However, this is not a recommendation to buy / hold / sell the stock at the time of publishing this report.
  • The securities quoted are for illustration purpose only and are not recommendatory
  • RC Capital Management may hold position in any of the companies mentioned in the report at the time of publishing the same. Its partners may hold a position in this company in their individual capacity at the time of publishing.
  • Neither RC Capital Management nor its partners have received any compensation from any company mentioned in this report for the preparation of this report.
  • There is no conflict of interest for RC Capital Management / it’s partners due to publishing this report

Subscription

Enter your email address if you would like to be notified when a new post is posted:

I agree to be emailed to confirm my subscription to this list

Recent Posts

Select category to filter posts

Archives